EYE OF HORUS - The independent DOCTOR WHO resource - link to front page
Link to EYE OF HORUS HOME Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 7 Link to DOCTOR WHO CLASSIC SERIES Link to DOCTOR WHO NEWS Link to EXCLUSIVE COMPETITIONS + EDITORIAL FEATURES Link to REVIEWS - DVD + AUDIO + PRINT Link to AMAZON.CO.UK - DOCTOR WHO official store Link to SEARCH within eyeofhorus.org.uk
 
DOCTOR WHO CLASSIC SERIES 63-89
Classic Series related sections
BIG FINISH audioplays
EOH GIVEAWAYS
FROM HARTNELL TO MCGANN
Reviews based upon DVD, VHS and CD releases
   
EPISODE GUIDE
Choose a Doctor
WILLIAM HARTNELL 1963-66
Choose an Episode

FIRST DOCTOR | PLANET OF GIANTS

 
"...Do you know why I'm a success, Mr Farrow?
Because I've never allowed the word "can't" to exist..."
 

STORY PLOTLINE

The main doors of the TARDIS open of their own accord just before it materialises, causing it to run out of control. On emerging, the travellers discover that the ship has been reduced in size and they are now only about an inch tall.

DVD EXTRAS

  • COMMENTARY Vision mixer Clive Doig, special sounds creator Brian Hodgson, make-up supervisor Sonia Markham and floor assistant David Tilley. Moderated by Mark Ayres
  • EPISODE 3 AND 4 RECONSTRUCTION Originally shot as a four-part story, the final two episodes of PLANET OF GIANTS were edited into a single episode for transmission. Using the original scripts, newly recorded dialogue and animation, this feature gives viewers and idea of how the original four-part version might have appeared
  • REDISCOVERING THE URGE TO LIVE The team behind the reconstruction explain how it was put together
  • SUDDENLY SUSANCarole Ann Ford talks about her role as the Doctor’s granddaughter and the first companion in the TARDIS in this interview originally recorded for 2003’s THE STORY OF DOCTOR WHO
  • THE LAMBERT TAPES - THE DOCTORDOCTOR WHO’s original producer looks back on her time on the series in the second part of this interview recorded for THE STORY OF DOCTOR WHO
  • Prop Design Plans (DVD-ROM only – to be viewed on PC/Mac)
  • Radio Times Listings (DVD-ROM) + Programme Subtitles + Production Information Subtitles + Photo Gallery + Coming Soon Trailer + Digitally remastered picture and sound quality

COMMENT  Spoliers ahead

Magical.

Perhaps, that’s the only word.

It’s August 2012 and we’re revelling in a magical William Hartnell adventure from the monochromatic era of humming, overheating cathode ray tubes and pea-souper smog. Complete with clasped-hook cloak, Hartnell diligently performs as the brusque alien with an extraordinarily advanced yet flawed time-space ship, DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS is a wonderfully evocative three-parter that opened the second season (ah, ‘older’ fans will relish that wording instead of the current labelling of ‘series’) but it would seem that the Louis Marks penned story had had a traumatic (or, perhaps, difficult or circuitous) route to air.

Originally planned as the first-ever broadcast story (eventually replaced by DOCTOR WHO – 100,000 BC: AN UNEARTHLY CHILD), the story could not be developed sufficiently enough to warrant the financial investment and was shelved. However, it was re-commissioned with Louis Marks submitting a four-episode script that, under the direction of Donald Wilson (BBC’s Head of Serials), was truncated to three episodes as it deemed to be “too slow” in dramatic action.

With its first release on DVD (single-disc), BBC DVD has delivered a pristine print and aurally clean version of DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS that is a welcome addition to the ever growing back catalogue, and whilst it may not be the most emotionally stirring, intellectually taxing stories in the history of the drama series it has some credibility for its ahead-of-its-time viewpoint on agricultural chemical & pesticide use and consequences.

In the first of DOCTOR WHO DVD its kind, DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS has been “reconstructed” with more episodes than it originally had. Assiduously, taking the script of the abandoned fourth episode (that has been combined into a new third episode) reconstruction experts (led by the legendary DOCTOR WHO fan, Ian Levine) has recorded a new soundtrack and amalgamated existing film material to “match” in order to create an all-new 25-minute episode. Unsurprisingly, the result is genius and a credit to the production team (and to the BBC for approving the venture; a venture that should be repeated for other ‘missing’ episodes).

The story of this reconstruction, REDISCOVERING THE URGE TO LIVE, is fascinatingly documented with interviews with Levine (“…a labour of love, … and work with your heroes…”), BBC DVD features producer, Ed Stradling, actors Toby Hadoke and John Guilor (voicing the role of the First Doctor, who described working with the original cast as like “…working with The Beatles”), and CLASSIC SERIES actors & original TARDIS companions, Carole Ann Ford (“…a very talkative story…”) and William Russell (“…my memory is entirely with a box of matches the size of telegraph poles…”). Even if the prospect of enduring an episode, that was originally deemed to be to dull and slow, is too daunting I recommend indulging in a caffeine drink as you will be wholly rewarded.

Opening with the upbeat dance tune of “John Smith and the Common Men” (from DOCTOR WHO – 100,000 BC: AN UNEARTHLY CHILD), in SUDDENLY SUSAN, the perennially charming Carole Ann Ford – recorded in 2003 – charts the development (or not, depending on your point of view) of her character, Susan, across the first and second seasons of the series. Asserting the potential dramatic fact that the character could have been “…hundreds of years old…” (A Time Lady with regenerative abilities?), Ford recalls the series’ filming, her working relationship with William Hartnell (“…we were genuinely fond of each other…” and “…there was an edge to his performance… an unexploded bomb…”), on her fame (“…it got quite frantic at time. It was like being a pop star…”), on her favourite story (“…just beautiful…”) and, of course, DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS (“…part fun, part nightmare…).

Unlike the contents of a disappointing Christmas Cracker complete with its tawdry & cheap contents that cost a mere handful of ‘coppers’, THE LAMBERT TAPES is a filler ‘featurette’ that delivers an explosion rather than that lukewarm ‘snap’ when opened.

Certainly, if it was not for the tenacity and courage of her convictions then DOCTOR WHO may not have endured for nearly five decades; Verity Lambert deserves all the plaudits that both fans and the television industry can offer. In this documentary, with Lambert recorded in 2003, she re-outlines the original premise of the series and the Doctor’s character (the NEW SERIES producer’s should take not) and how her lead actor “…embodied the character…” and how the minuscule financial budget forced her team to “…use their imagination…”

Continuing to analyse the genesis of the series, Lambert confirms that the BBC Head of Drama, Sidney Newman was “…a huge supporter of DOCTOR WHO…” but initially “…hated the music but admitted he was wrong later…” Additionally, she refused to agree with media critics that the series was too scary but criticised the BBC Executives of the 1980s for its erroneous shifting the series around the broadcast schedule that resulted in viewers unable to consistently follow it (even though she described the production of later episodes as “…very camp. It didn’t work for me”).

The COMING SOON feature is for the CLASSIC SERIES revisit to the 2001-released DVD, DOCTOR WHO – VENGEANCE ON VAROS. If there was one story that could be re-edited as a single 45-minute episode then this would be the first candidate, however this re-evaluation release does not do so. It is released on 10 September 2012.

DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS includes the usual PHOTO GALLERY, PDF MATERIAL and RADIO TIMES material in addition to a supplementary commentary from the 1964 crew.

STUDIO COMMENTARY highlights.

Moderated by Mark Ayres (yes, he does sound like Toby Hadoke), memories from the distant past are cajoled forth from Brian Hodgson (Special Sounds), Sonia Markham (Make-up), Clive Dig (Vision Mixer Editor) and David Tilley (Floor Assistant).

On PLANET OF GIANTS, Clive Doig: Not one of the greatest.

On a single sound effect within the TARDIS, Brian Hodgson: My only contribution to the story.

On the provision of make-up, Sonia Markham: Relatively easy for this one, apart from dirt on the faces. Always the worry was Bill Hartnell’s wig.

Fact: The story was originally titled, DOCTOR WHO – THE MINUSCULES.

On William Hartnell, Sonia Markham: He was nervous about his lines and what to do. Once he got to know you, he was friendly.

On the director of episode three, Douglas Camfield, Clive Doig: New generation of director.

On the surface, DOCTOR WHO – PLANET OF GIANTS could be regarded as a dull, dreary and pedestrian story (I hesitate to the use the phrase ‘adventure’ in its literal term), but its merits overwhelming outweigh its obvious shortcomings (remember, it was 1964 and television was still in its infancy).

With this refresh re-appraisal, fans will be able to not only witness the magnificence of Hartnell’s definitive Doctor and the reconstruction of a truly ‘lost episode’ that, ironically, never was.

EOH CONTRIBUTOR
MATTHEW WALTER
EOH RATING

EOH RATING 9/10

INFORMATION

WILLIAM HARTNELL IS THE DOCTOR

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD cover

 

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD menu version 1
ENLARGE IMAGE

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD menu version 2
ENLARGE IMAGE

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD SUDDENLY SUSAN documentary
ENLARGE IMAGE

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD THE LAMBERT FILES documentary
ENLARGE IMAGE

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD commentary Carol Ann Ford and William Russell
ENLARGE IMAGE

DOCTOR WHO PLANET OF GIANTS DVD John Guilor as William Hartnell's Doctor's 'voice'
ENLARGE IMAGE

 

DVD Release 20 August 2012

PREVIOUS EPISODE - THE PLANET OF THE SPIDERS NEXT EPISODE

Online visitor hits since 13 April 2003

© www.eyeofhorus.org.uk 2015
(Extra © information visit here)

"DOCTOR WHO commentary since 1983"

Email us EDITORIAL EMAIL - We do not reply to emails

Follow us on TWITTER - eyeofhorus.org.uk on Twitter


Contact us - EDITORIAL EMAIL
Link back to HOME - EYE OF HORUS Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 2 Link to CLASSIC SERIES 1963-96 Link to CURRENT NEWS Link to BIG FINISH AUDIO Link to EYE OF HORUS - EDITORIAL + GIVEAWAYS Link to DOCTOR WHO MERCHANDISE EMAIL - EOH cannot reply to all emails due to time restrictions