EYE OF HORUS - The independent DOCTOR WHO resource - link to front page
Link to EYE OF HORUS HOME Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 7 Link to DOCTOR WHO CLASSIC SERIES Link to DOCTOR WHO NEWS Link to EXCLUSIVE COMPETITIONS + EDITORIAL FEATURES Link to REVIEWS - DVD + AUDIO + PRINT Link to AMAZON.CO.UK - DOCTOR WHO official store Link to SEARCH within eyeofhorus.org.uk
   
MERCHANDISE REVIEWS
Choose DVD
Choose AUDIO (Audiobooks and Music)
Choose BOOKS (Fiction and Non-Fiction)
Choose DOCTOR WHO LIVE EVENTS
Choose DOCTOR WHO MAGAZINE
Choose CLASSIC SERIES TOYS
Choose FORBIDDEN PLANET EXCLUSIVE TOYS
     
AUDIOBOOK and SERIES OST REVIEWS  
Choose a DOCTOR WHO UNABRIDGED review
Choose a DOCTOR WHO ABRIDGED review

Choose a DESTINY OF THE DOCTOR review
Choose a SERPENT CREST (2011) review
Choose a DEMON QUEST (2010) review
Choose a HORNETS' NEST (2009) review
Choose a SARAH JANE ADVENTURES review
Choose a BLAKE'S 7 review
Choose a TORCHWOOD review
Choose a SOUNDTRACK & DOCUMENTARY review

         

DOCTOR WHO | DOCTOR WHO - THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD Volume 1

 
"...unequivocally, Colin Baker sparkles..."


PLOTLINE

Doctor Who and the Mysterious Planet: The TARDIS has been taken out of time and the Doctor has been brought before a court of his fellow Time Lords. There the sinister Valeyard accuses the Doctor of breaking Gallifrey's most important law and interfering in the affairs of other planets. If the Valeyard can prove him guilty, the Doctor must sacrifice his remaining regenerations...

Doctor Who: Mindwarp: The sinister prosecutor, the Valeyard, presents the High Council of Time Lords with the second piece of evidence against the Doctor...

Read by Linda Bellingham and Colin Baker.

COMMENT - SPOILERS AHEAD

1985. It was a tortuous time in the series' history. Its production had been placed on-hold after BBC Executives deemed that it had lost its creativity and credibility. Effectively, the series had been placed on 'trial' and was given one more chance to re-establish itself as being worthy of broadcast on BBC ONE.

From this traumatic time, delivered a fourteen episode story that would, ironically, mirror the potential 'summary execution' of the series if it was found guilty. Series Script Editor, Eric Saward's conceit of a THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD was prophetic, poking overt derision toward those BBC Executives who, it would seem by any means, wanted the series to whither & die, however such was the clumsiness of its structure and banal content even die-hard fans lost hope in the series remaining a fixture of BBC ONE. Bar one or two episodes, it was an undisputed calamity of ineptitude, so could the TARGET novelisations redeem THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD's reputation and garner a new set of fans?

Certainly, AUDIOGO's two-volume release of THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD's four separate novels is risky, and, even more so, to issue them as 'boxed-set' and not individually.

THE MYSTERIOUS PLANET - Terrance Dicks (1988) - read by Lynda Bellingham

MINDWARP - Phillip Martin (1989) - read by Colin Baker

TERROR OF THE VERVOIDS - Pip and Jane Baker (1988) - read by Bonnie Langford

THE ULTIMATE FOE - Pip and Jane Baker (1988) - read by Michael Jayston

So, volume one's double-header release, THE MYSTERIOUS PLANET and MINDWARP.

Returning to the Time Lord Court Room, Lynda Bellingham confidently reads/performs Terrance Dicks' novelisation of Robert Holmes' original screenplay. With that said, you would have thought that such an amalgamation of talent of two distinguished writers that the first four episodes of THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD would have heralded a thrilling, absorbing and dynamic adventure for the Sixth Doctor and Peri to be embroiled within at the start of the drama's SEASON 23. However, THE MYSTERIOUS PLANET remains a prime example of placid, flabby writing that aimlessly meanders with carelessness that at time is painful to read. In effect, it is a CLASSIC SERIES two-parter injected with a jelly-filling that plumps up the core story.

And there lays the problem that Bellingham's presentation. It's not her eloquent and vehement performance, crafting carefully delineated idiosyncratic & colourful characters at every turn of the page, but it is soporific content that is she's ploughing through. In this instance, the shortest straw had been drawn.

Certainly, Bellingham relishes bringing the caustic, sarcastic and flippant Sixth Doctor to life, and injecting a marginalisation and mild annoyingness with her characterisation of Peri Brown that was aptly realised throughout the broadcast version. Suitably, her Glitz and Dibber are delightfully as 'wide' as ONLY FOOLS AND HORSES' Derek and Rodney with a undercurrent of psychopathic militancy that was skimmed across with too much flippancy originally on-screen by Tony Selby and Glen Murphy.

The sound treatment (by Simon Power of MEON SOUND) attributed to Bellingham's voice as Drathro, the L3 Robot, instils a true chilling threat to the otherwise light-weight text; resonant, recalcitrant and irreconcilable.

Whist the first two-thirds of the novel is as pedestrian as old aged pensioner assailing an ice-coated pavement whilst wearing carpet slippers, it is the final third (disc three) that truly awakens this slumbering giant. Whilst the Court Room punctuations become less exasperating, Bellingham's reading rattles along with ascending momentum that will leave you breathless.

Take a leap of faith, it may not be taut or dynamic but allow Bellingham to guide you through the machinations and double-crossing that permeate the impossible planet of Ravalox.

Across a four-disc presentation, Colin Baker reads Phillip Martin's (own) novelisation of episode 5 to 8 of THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD, MINDWARP , with a relish and energy that becomes a tsunami of beguiling characterisation and joyous narrative to listen to. Surprisingly, this is Baker's first novelisation reading under the AUDIOGO brand, and, if this is the result, it shouldn't be the last.

Regally reassuring, Baker's Sixth Doctor is perfectly pitched as you would expect - terse, authoritative yet dutifully reverent -whilst the haplessly bemused Peri is marginally "up-scaled" to be more effective than her stereotypical televised characterisation. Throughout MINDWARP, Phillip Martin indulgently parachutes-in an array of conflicting characters that certainly Baker handles with an impressive deftness and athletic vocal agility that other readers in the DOCTOR WHO novelisation audio range would be directed to listen to before embarking on their own commission.

Baker's financially-focussed reptilian, Sil is thoroughly repulsive, though his iconic vocal 'cackle' is more reminiscent of BAGPUSS' Professor Yaffle than a vile, subservient Thoros Betan, however, the actor expertly mimics Sil's original strangulated vocal staccato rhythm that has ensured the iconic character's enduring fan appreciation. Naturally, Baker delivers a King Yrcanos gloriously ebullient yet - thankfully - restrained that melds into the story's development without being over-bearing or comical as the character had been in the televised version.

Interesting, MINDWARP seems to flit less between the machinations on Thoros Beta and the manipulations aboard the Time Lord Court Flagship, and this allows the action unfold at a more measured rate than THE MYSTERIOUS PLANET had, and, to that end, is far more enjoyable and appreciative.

DOCTOR WHO - THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD VOLUME ONE is a Curate's Egg, with, considering the writing talent of Robert Holmes, the first three-disc adventutre being the weakest, whilst Phillip Martin's tale of economic greed and the seeking of medically implanted Nirvana. Nevertheless, the release (along with expected VOLUME 2) ensures that the troubled all-too-short era of the (underrated) Sixth Doctor is not forgotten unceremoniously.

BUY DISCS OR DOWNLOAD DIRECT FROM AUDIOGO

 

EOH CONTRIBUTOR

MATTHEW WALTER

EOH RATING

eyeofhorus.org.uk BBC AUDIO rating: 7/10

INFORMATION

DOCTOR WHO COLIN BAKER is the Doctor

DOCTOR WHO - THE TRIAL OF A TIME LORD Volume 1  (2013) AUDIOGO
CLICK TO ENLARGE


 

Released 02.09.2013

RRP: £18.35

Duration: 7hrs 55 mins approx.

 

Online visitor hits since 13 April 2003

© www.eyeofhorus.org.uk 2015
(Extra © information visit here)

"DOCTOR WHO commentary since 1983"

Email us EDITORIAL EMAIL - We do not reply to emails

Follow us on TWITTER - eyeofhorus.org.uk on Twitter


Contact us - EDITORIAL EMAIL
Link back to HOME - EYE OF HORUS Link to DOCTOR WHO NEW SERIES 2 Link to CLASSIC SERIES 1963-96 Link to CURRENT NEWS Link to BIG FINISH AUDIO Link to EYE OF HORUS - EDITORIAL + GIVEAWAYS Link to DOCTOR WHO MERCHANDISE EMAIL - EOH cannot reply to all emails due to time restrictions